Secular Reincarnation Fails: Bayesian Limits & Personal Identity
Formal Argument: Existence is Not Evidence of Immortality
A critique of Huemer’s Bayesian “Existence → Immortality” inference via semantic equivocation
1. Bayesian Principle of Evidence
Evidence E supports hypothesis H if and only if:
P(E | H) > P(E | ¬H)
2. Hypotheses & Evidence Definitions
- Hperm: A permissive theory of persons (personal identity can recur; one may live more than once).
- Hrest: A restrictive theory of persons (personal identity is unrepeatable; one can live at most once).
- E: “You exist now” (an indexical self-locating proposition).
3. Huemer’s Core Claim
P(E | Hperm) > P(E | Hrest)
Therefore, by (1), E confers Bayesian support on Hperm—asserting that your present existence constitutes evidence for reincarnation.
4. The Equivocation Problem
The proposition E shifts substantive content across competing hypotheses:
- • Under Hperm: “Someone with properties {A, B, C} exists now.”
- • Under Hrest: “Someone with properties {A, B, C, D} exists now.”
Hence Eperm ≠ Erest. The evidential term shifts meaning, rendering the likelihood comparison undefined across distinct sample spaces.
5. Bayesian Comparability Condition
For Bayes’ theorem to apply, the evidence proposition E must remain invariant across all hypotheses under test. If E varies, the ratio P(E | Hperm) / P(E | Hrest) is mathematically undefined.
6. Semantic Repair & Symmetry
Fix a single, non-equivocating proposition E*: “A being with {A, B, C} exists now.”
Under this consistent definition:
P(E* | Hperm) = P(E* | Hrest)
Any evidential asymmetry favoring Hperm is eliminated.
7. Conclusion
Huemer’s argument collapses into a definitional shift rather than a probabilistic result. Once the indexical proposition “you exist now” is held uniform across hypotheses, existence confers no Bayesian support for secular reincarnation or personal immortality.
Explanatory Note: This formal analysis concerns strictly the evidential relationship between present existence and competing personal identity theories, not the broader metaphysics of mind. Properties A, B, C, and D are schematic placeholders with no empirical commitments. The argument shows that introspection cannot establish an evidential advantage: existence alone cannot perform the required confirmatory work.
How to Cite This Work
APA (7th ed.):
Allen, L. R. (2025). Secular reincarnation: Existence, evidence, and the boundaries of Bayesian reasoning (Preprint). Luke Allen, PhD. https://lukeallenphd.com/secular-reincarnation-fails
Chicago (Author-Date):
Allen, Luke R. 2025. "Secular Reincarnation: Existence, Evidence, and the Boundaries of Bayesian Reasoning." Preprint. https://lukeallenphd.com/secular-reincarnation-fails.
BibTeX:
@misc{allen2025secular,
author = {Allen, Luke R.},
title = {Secular Reincarnation: Existence, Evidence, and the Boundaries of Bayesian Reasoning},
year = {2025},
howpublished = {Preprint},
url = {https://lukeallenphd.com/secular-reincarnation-fails},
note = {ORCID: 0000-0001-5420-2992}
}